Dear Robert,
An interesting last post (15th Sept) - be careful my friend, that was almost an apology! I repeat once again that you have NOTHING to apologise for. You seem to value my opinion but then when I criticise constructively you go off on one of your regular forays into paranoia. Lets deal with a few points.
1. Sorry if what I said about 'Face pt 4' you didn't like. My overall criticism was that putting up a section of a longer piece I find rather odd. 'Face' was a beautiful piece of music and just putting up a bit of it made no sense. Would you listen to just 5 minutes of Suppers Ready?
2. I am not in the least bit possessive about 'I keep the one I love in the freezer' so attempting to insult it doesn't upset me one jot. However your memory appears to once again be rather distorted. You suggest it is like a 'pop song' - hmmm. If you remember when I wrote it I really was not in the least bit happy with it but was told "man, this will be one of the best songs we've ever done, we've got to include it" - now I wonder who said that - ah yes it was you. It was also you who suggested that this song feature at almost every gig because "the fans love it and I love singing it" (again a quote from you). True over time I did become fond of this piece, mostly thanks to praise received from fans and the rest of the band yourself included. You will recall that I never wanted to call it "I keep the one I love in the freezer" and I think it possibly annoyed you that I never told you what it was about. This was not just to wind you up, this is because of a fundamental belief I have that it doesn't matter what the writer thinks it's about - it is what it means to the listener. You have chosen to interpret it to be about some sicko murderer which I think says a lot more about you than it does me. Have another read of the lyrics - could it mean anything else?
3. As I said at the start of my message - you don't have anything to apologise for but I must be totally honest that I was rather offended that you thought it was me who sent you an email from Zed. You logic here beggars belief - why would someone who is so "lacking in imagination and just plain dull" (your blog Aug 8th) do something like this?
4. Without You. Well done my friend. I have always adored this piece and I think you have done a reasonable job. True the drums are appalling but this is not your fault - I have yet to hear convincing 'computer drums'. One thing I think you got wrong was the tempo - was this supposed to be an amphetamine induced version? I think it could do with some severe slowing down (please note this is supposed to be CONSTRUCTIVE criticism - so please attempt to hold back you tirade of abuse).
Finally, I am sorry if my 'normal' life offends you (Bank Manager is surprisingly close) I have a wife whom I adore and 2 fantastic kids and overall I have never been happier - but don't take my word for it. We sit down every Sunday for a family roast (I hate to blow my own trumpet but I do a mean roast dinner) and I'd like to invite you along to join us at your convenience if you can stand the drudgery. If money is tight, just let me know I will be more than happy to pay your train fare (I'm assuming that you still refuse to drive anywhere). Any Sunday is good for us.
As always I will end by wishing you nothing but the best and I hope I am wrong in anticipating another vitriolic and scathing reply on your blog.
Graham.